Before the civil war, downtown was a dense place of souks, offices, worship, cafés, shortcuts and arguments. The war tore it apart. Reconstruction then cleared and remade much of what remained. Old streets and buildings disappeared; ancient layers were exposed, removed, saved selectively or turned into fragments of a new image. We lost more than attractive facades. We lost evidence of how people had lived together, badly and beautifully, in the same city.
Beirut has become very good at calling erasure progress. We destroy, tidy up the drawing and act as though memory is an obstacle to modern life. Some people call that fashionable. I think it is lazy. A new city needs somewhere to stand, and a blank surface cannot tell you where you are.
That was the problem I saw in the original park scheme. Its curves and managed water feature looked elegant from above. On the ground, I feared another landscape that would move people through without asking them to stay. In the middle of a rebuilt centre already accused of forgetting, a generic park would repeat the same mistake at a smaller scale.